It seems that the EU wants to make injunctions the default remedy in patent cases. This is quite troubling because of the hold up nature of patents: it means you could extort an disproportionate rent from accidental use of a minor infraction. It will mainly aid patent trolls, since it seems important safeguards are missing:
-
You can pursue an injunction even before you have a ruling on the validity. Given how many crappy patents are issued, this is a huge problem.
-
There is no proportionality with regard to the actual value of the patent. Many infringements happen because the invention is close to obvious and has been independently recreated. This means the invention should be considered nearly useless, and not be available for extortion.
-
There is no recognition that the negotiation overhead for possible hundreds of patents needed for typical computer based techniques would be prohibitive for small companies, and could strongly inhibit innovations.